Why is medical background (to be a physician) so unbelievably long here within the United States?
I'm a 20 year-old college student whose parents once wanted him to be a doctor, but who flatly refused.
It wasn't because of finances or anything (I'm on a full-merit scholarship presently, and wouldn't have an issue paying for any medical school), but the thing is it's SO LONG!
People that I know that live in Russia or surrounded by other countries can practice medicine in just three to four years, lacking going to undergraduate, and they have the same quality of treatment as US physicians.
But here contained by the US, it's 4 years of undergrad, 4 years of Medical School, THEN 3+ years of residency. (Not to mention the myriad of tests and licensing exams in between!)
So why is becoming a doctor so long here surrounded by the United States?
I calculated it out, and I wouldn't even start working full time as a doctor until I were 28! And to think of all the debts I'd accrue by afterwards!
Answers:
Personally, I'd rather walk to a doctor with that much school and the 3 years of residence. I don't want to go to a doctor who have only been studying for only 3 years.
Only your first two years of med school are spent in classes, after that you do rotations within hospitals. And residencies are paid, real work - though obviously the take-home pay is very little compared to the amount of work done. So ultimately you're only doing two years of coursework beyond your undergraduate degree, roughly the same as any Master's or PhD program.
Weeds out the quacks!
why do you think heads of state of other countries come to America to be treated when seriously not at your best?
America is sue happy... mal-practice insurance is insanely expensive and required. I think if doctors were trained smaller number then it would be even higher. I don't know how you can say that the talent of treatment is the same without any statistics.
There is a reason why some people who were practicing physicians contained by Russia are taking jobs as technicians here in the US. They just do not own the same depth of education and training as US trained physicians.
I've been through the process, and still discern like there is SO much more I could have academic. After the 8 yrs of school, you know just enough to be unsafe. It's in residency that you really learn to practice medicine. The truth is, we never stop erudition. It doesn'e end with med school graduation or completion of residency - it's a lifelong process.
I conjecture if you knew more about it, you'd find that countries with smaller quantity stringent educational requirements do not have the same ability of care as those with higher requirements.
We don't practice drug for the money, or because our parents wanted us to. Those of us who are meant to do it put up with the hassle and debts of training to be capable of do what we are called to do.
I'm glad you aren't going into medicine - there are plenty of other opportunity for a smart person like yourself. Find what you love and do that. Source(s): I'm a physician, and I was 30 when I get a "real job".
Simple -just ask yourself this question.
If you were having surgery - would you want the guy to own 3-4 years of training (equivalent to a bachelor's degree) or would you want them to have 8 years of school, and 3 years of intern work?
It is so long because of the multitudes of diseases and factors in someone's health. One point could be triggering another. Also, something could be presenting itself as one disease and be something all entirely different. It takes those years to learn the entire body, it's working systems, how they function, why they function the path they do, and what different diseases, chemicals, allergies, stressors, accidents etc... it could be. and that is BEFORE you begin to even swot treatments.
I suggest if you are going to be a lazy doctor who doesn't give a rat's butt about anyone's condition by not studying why it may be that way, then please please please tell your parents I said not to force you into it. It's a not easy job, filled with stressful long hours and it have to come first in your life. Not second, not third, not even fourth or fifth.
So Go to Russia or where on earth ever to get your degree and see if you can then practice here.
The criteria is the criteria. Deal near it... and move on.
Same quality of treatment my αss, there's a origin no one in the US has died of swine flu compared to over a hundred contained by Mexico.
I heard the point of having undergrad is to both weed out people because so oodles people want to study medicine (yet this means population that have other qualities to become a doctor will never get surrounded by because they weren't good at calculus, a subject that's mostly useless as a doctor unless in the rare crust you go into building new MRI machines or something).
It's also used so that people who aren't fully sure what craft they want can switch to something else with little consequence. Dunno, I went to med school surrounded by Mexico where you don't do undergrad. 4 years of med school (first 2 years in classrooms and the other two a mix of classroom classes and clinical rotations within hospitals), 1 year of internship where you work and virtually live in a hospital working under supervision of attendings and residents and a final year exclusive to Mexico where on earth you do a community service as a junior doctor in some random clinic in a rural community. You do 3 exams and when they release you from the service you graduate.
I personally like the mexican system more. If you're sure to become a doctor, you don't want to waste your time next to endless art history 101 classes that aren't relevant. People will quit the career anyways (most of them during the first 2 years). If you have made it to become an intern, it's unlikely you'll drop out very soon.
I do agree, it's a long career. It's worst as a student because you aren't earning any money and few peope have the free time to enjoy parttime jobs as students. I like being an intern more. You're in reality doing something useful and while you still respond to your university a bit, you're now working.
However, medicine is a long trade not because the material is in particular difficult, it's because it's only just an insane amount of material that needs to be covered. And even then, I grain like the material was covered to little. I's importantly be suspicious of an educational system that teaches you everything about pills in just 3 years.
Residency is when you have already graduate as a general doctor. You choose a specialty like general surgery and acquire trained and being paid for it (albeit not a great salary though) working insanely long hours for a trustworthy number of years to that goal. A surgeon will not be taught public health topics for example. They are qualified to operate. Source(s): Mexican intern.
Doctors are paid more here than in Russia, so you'd be making adequate to pay back your student loans.
You really can't look at it as "school take so long". It's not like your career is going to be "attend med school". Your career is tablets. I really don't think the length of school is a decide factor for most would-be med students.
yeah i wonder that too... russia india uk all hold 4 to 5 years of med school and they produce just as good doctors (considering the world seem to be heading to indian doctors for treatment). but even for those countries a good income does not begin before 28 because after a nonspecific medical course of 5 years there is specialization for another 2 years. then setting up in countries resembling india and russia is far tougher than in the US.
In general i think the medical studies extend longer because doctors are really defining... we want to be sure they know their stuff!
good luck with med school... 8 years will leave behind in a blurr till the time you enjoy it :)
and dont worry abt debt the reduction is terrible the bank lending you money might move about bust by the time you graduate ;) (just kidding... as a doctor you will recover that money faster than you can imagine)
It's done to ensure that the graduating student/physician is exceptional. The block is set very high here in the US both surrounded by terms of admission criteria and the road to get in attendance.
Related Questions:
Is at hand a medication to darken your skin?
Cell phones and cancer, cell phones don't produce ionized radiation, so how do they trigger cancer?
I inevitability to know roughly speaking Adderall XR. Anyone lift it, or freshly know in the region of it?
It wasn't because of finances or anything (I'm on a full-merit scholarship presently, and wouldn't have an issue paying for any medical school), but the thing is it's SO LONG!
People that I know that live in Russia or surrounded by other countries can practice medicine in just three to four years, lacking going to undergraduate, and they have the same quality of treatment as US physicians.
But here contained by the US, it's 4 years of undergrad, 4 years of Medical School, THEN 3+ years of residency. (Not to mention the myriad of tests and licensing exams in between!)
So why is becoming a doctor so long here surrounded by the United States?
I calculated it out, and I wouldn't even start working full time as a doctor until I were 28! And to think of all the debts I'd accrue by afterwards!
Answers:
Personally, I'd rather walk to a doctor with that much school and the 3 years of residence. I don't want to go to a doctor who have only been studying for only 3 years.
Only your first two years of med school are spent in classes, after that you do rotations within hospitals. And residencies are paid, real work - though obviously the take-home pay is very little compared to the amount of work done. So ultimately you're only doing two years of coursework beyond your undergraduate degree, roughly the same as any Master's or PhD program.
Weeds out the quacks!
why do you think heads of state of other countries come to America to be treated when seriously not at your best?
America is sue happy... mal-practice insurance is insanely expensive and required. I think if doctors were trained smaller number then it would be even higher. I don't know how you can say that the talent of treatment is the same without any statistics.
There is a reason why some people who were practicing physicians contained by Russia are taking jobs as technicians here in the US. They just do not own the same depth of education and training as US trained physicians.
I've been through the process, and still discern like there is SO much more I could have academic. After the 8 yrs of school, you know just enough to be unsafe. It's in residency that you really learn to practice medicine. The truth is, we never stop erudition. It doesn'e end with med school graduation or completion of residency - it's a lifelong process.
I conjecture if you knew more about it, you'd find that countries with smaller quantity stringent educational requirements do not have the same ability of care as those with higher requirements.
We don't practice drug for the money, or because our parents wanted us to. Those of us who are meant to do it put up with the hassle and debts of training to be capable of do what we are called to do.
I'm glad you aren't going into medicine - there are plenty of other opportunity for a smart person like yourself. Find what you love and do that. Source(s): I'm a physician, and I was 30 when I get a "real job".
Simple -just ask yourself this question.
If you were having surgery - would you want the guy to own 3-4 years of training (equivalent to a bachelor's degree) or would you want them to have 8 years of school, and 3 years of intern work?
It is so long because of the multitudes of diseases and factors in someone's health. One point could be triggering another. Also, something could be presenting itself as one disease and be something all entirely different. It takes those years to learn the entire body, it's working systems, how they function, why they function the path they do, and what different diseases, chemicals, allergies, stressors, accidents etc... it could be. and that is BEFORE you begin to even swot treatments.
I suggest if you are going to be a lazy doctor who doesn't give a rat's butt about anyone's condition by not studying why it may be that way, then please please please tell your parents I said not to force you into it. It's a not easy job, filled with stressful long hours and it have to come first in your life. Not second, not third, not even fourth or fifth.
So Go to Russia or where on earth ever to get your degree and see if you can then practice here.
The criteria is the criteria. Deal near it... and move on.
Same quality of treatment my αss, there's a origin no one in the US has died of swine flu compared to over a hundred contained by Mexico.
I heard the point of having undergrad is to both weed out people because so oodles people want to study medicine (yet this means population that have other qualities to become a doctor will never get surrounded by because they weren't good at calculus, a subject that's mostly useless as a doctor unless in the rare crust you go into building new MRI machines or something).
It's also used so that people who aren't fully sure what craft they want can switch to something else with little consequence. Dunno, I went to med school surrounded by Mexico where you don't do undergrad. 4 years of med school (first 2 years in classrooms and the other two a mix of classroom classes and clinical rotations within hospitals), 1 year of internship where you work and virtually live in a hospital working under supervision of attendings and residents and a final year exclusive to Mexico where on earth you do a community service as a junior doctor in some random clinic in a rural community. You do 3 exams and when they release you from the service you graduate.
I personally like the mexican system more. If you're sure to become a doctor, you don't want to waste your time next to endless art history 101 classes that aren't relevant. People will quit the career anyways (most of them during the first 2 years). If you have made it to become an intern, it's unlikely you'll drop out very soon.
I do agree, it's a long career. It's worst as a student because you aren't earning any money and few peope have the free time to enjoy parttime jobs as students. I like being an intern more. You're in reality doing something useful and while you still respond to your university a bit, you're now working.
However, medicine is a long trade not because the material is in particular difficult, it's because it's only just an insane amount of material that needs to be covered. And even then, I grain like the material was covered to little. I's importantly be suspicious of an educational system that teaches you everything about pills in just 3 years.
Residency is when you have already graduate as a general doctor. You choose a specialty like general surgery and acquire trained and being paid for it (albeit not a great salary though) working insanely long hours for a trustworthy number of years to that goal. A surgeon will not be taught public health topics for example. They are qualified to operate. Source(s): Mexican intern.
Doctors are paid more here than in Russia, so you'd be making adequate to pay back your student loans.
You really can't look at it as "school take so long". It's not like your career is going to be "attend med school". Your career is tablets. I really don't think the length of school is a decide factor for most would-be med students.
yeah i wonder that too... russia india uk all hold 4 to 5 years of med school and they produce just as good doctors (considering the world seem to be heading to indian doctors for treatment). but even for those countries a good income does not begin before 28 because after a nonspecific medical course of 5 years there is specialization for another 2 years. then setting up in countries resembling india and russia is far tougher than in the US.
In general i think the medical studies extend longer because doctors are really defining... we want to be sure they know their stuff!
good luck with med school... 8 years will leave behind in a blurr till the time you enjoy it :)
and dont worry abt debt the reduction is terrible the bank lending you money might move about bust by the time you graduate ;) (just kidding... as a doctor you will recover that money faster than you can imagine)
It's done to ensure that the graduating student/physician is exceptional. The block is set very high here in the US both surrounded by terms of admission criteria and the road to get in attendance.
Related Questions: