What is the application process close to for medical residency?
Also, how do acceptance rates vary? (meaning, like medical school, are they usually like 10% and under, or do you generally obtain in if your field is in dignified demand?)
Answers:
Although declining, the actual rate of acceptance for medical university in the US is between 40-50%. You may be getting your 10% number from individual statistics, for example the University of Oklahoma SOM accepts about 11% of applicants, Dartmouth accept closer to 2%. But with these stats it should be remembered that a single applicant applies to multiple schools, and that a single applicant can be accepted/rejected by multiple schools.
Regardless, the residency process have some similarities but many differences to the med school app process. First, there are currently more residency spots than US senior medical university graduates overall. Complicating this seemingly reassuring statement are the factors of superfluous applicants from the ranks of osteopathic grads, Caribbean grads, and foreign medical school graduates (some of whom may be already boarded and sub-specialized in their home countries).
You also hold to consider some specialties are much more competitive than others for various reasons like money and lifestyle/hours. Also there are some specialties that tend to draw certain personalities, thereby making orthopedic surgery for example more competitive than one would infer based simply on the nature and, er, intellectual challenge of the work.
Also one must consider that even contained by relatively non-competitive specialties, pockets of competitiveness exist in a given location or a given program. Internal Medicine may not be all that competitive across the board when compared to Ophthalmology, but getting an IM spot at Boston's Mass General is much tougher than getting an Ophtho spot in Birmingham I promise you.
A final consideration when looking at strict numbers is that med college seniors are a little wiser than your typical college kid. An M3 needs to begin planning his remaining time contained by med school around a certain specialty in direct to maximize his chances for success. Letters of Recommendation need to be gather, away rotations at desirable locations need to be solicited, essays need to be written, etc. For this reason, and also due to time/money constraints (one can't practically apply and travel to multiple residency programs in multiple specialties) there's much more self-selection involved.
The actual process is also very different. After interview season, you list a bunch of places you'd like to walk in descending order. Likewise the programs list a bunch of interviewees they'd resembling to train, and a computer matches everyone up very neatly and successfully. Most US allo grads get one of their top-3 choices if they applied selectively and smartly, and most programs fill their spots from the top 25-30 folks on their list. If not, adjectives the students without a spot and all the programs without a resident hop into an virtual tel-a-thon/fax-a-thon called the Scramble, which is a nightmare you can read about somewhere else.
At the end of the daytime nearly all US grads secure postgrad training by the end of Scramble week. The remainder are any there by choice (i.e. opting to pursue academic research, pursuing another advanced point like MBA or JD, or hitting the private sector as a consultant) or will manage to find a spot somewhere by July 1st. It's a rare bird indeed for a graduate of an American allopathic medical college to be working at Home Depot two years down the line.
With all that said and to finally answer your question, meeting rates for US allo grads range anywhere from 100% for dermatology and other ultra-competitive specialties to 50% for family medicine and other non-competitive ones. From a different point of vision, someone applying for family medicine or psychiatry is virtually guaranteed a position, while someone even with stellar boards, grades, and LORs have only slightly better than a coin-flip chance of matching derm or neurosurg. Match rates for osteopathic is slightly lower. For foreign old pupils it is exponentially tougher to match, due to a combination of questionable international curriculum standardization, language barriers, decrease training reimbursement by Medicare for foreign grads, and good old fashioned prejudice.
Related Questions:
Body fluids physio med college q?
Does anyone work as a pharmacist?
I want to be a heart surgeon...?
Answers:
Although declining, the actual rate of acceptance for medical university in the US is between 40-50%. You may be getting your 10% number from individual statistics, for example the University of Oklahoma SOM accepts about 11% of applicants, Dartmouth accept closer to 2%. But with these stats it should be remembered that a single applicant applies to multiple schools, and that a single applicant can be accepted/rejected by multiple schools.
Regardless, the residency process have some similarities but many differences to the med school app process. First, there are currently more residency spots than US senior medical university graduates overall. Complicating this seemingly reassuring statement are the factors of superfluous applicants from the ranks of osteopathic grads, Caribbean grads, and foreign medical school graduates (some of whom may be already boarded and sub-specialized in their home countries).
You also hold to consider some specialties are much more competitive than others for various reasons like money and lifestyle/hours. Also there are some specialties that tend to draw certain personalities, thereby making orthopedic surgery for example more competitive than one would infer based simply on the nature and, er, intellectual challenge of the work.
Also one must consider that even contained by relatively non-competitive specialties, pockets of competitiveness exist in a given location or a given program. Internal Medicine may not be all that competitive across the board when compared to Ophthalmology, but getting an IM spot at Boston's Mass General is much tougher than getting an Ophtho spot in Birmingham I promise you.
A final consideration when looking at strict numbers is that med college seniors are a little wiser than your typical college kid. An M3 needs to begin planning his remaining time contained by med school around a certain specialty in direct to maximize his chances for success. Letters of Recommendation need to be gather, away rotations at desirable locations need to be solicited, essays need to be written, etc. For this reason, and also due to time/money constraints (one can't practically apply and travel to multiple residency programs in multiple specialties) there's much more self-selection involved.
The actual process is also very different. After interview season, you list a bunch of places you'd like to walk in descending order. Likewise the programs list a bunch of interviewees they'd resembling to train, and a computer matches everyone up very neatly and successfully. Most US allo grads get one of their top-3 choices if they applied selectively and smartly, and most programs fill their spots from the top 25-30 folks on their list. If not, adjectives the students without a spot and all the programs without a resident hop into an virtual tel-a-thon/fax-a-thon called the Scramble, which is a nightmare you can read about somewhere else.
At the end of the daytime nearly all US grads secure postgrad training by the end of Scramble week. The remainder are any there by choice (i.e. opting to pursue academic research, pursuing another advanced point like MBA or JD, or hitting the private sector as a consultant) or will manage to find a spot somewhere by July 1st. It's a rare bird indeed for a graduate of an American allopathic medical college to be working at Home Depot two years down the line.
With all that said and to finally answer your question, meeting rates for US allo grads range anywhere from 100% for dermatology and other ultra-competitive specialties to 50% for family medicine and other non-competitive ones. From a different point of vision, someone applying for family medicine or psychiatry is virtually guaranteed a position, while someone even with stellar boards, grades, and LORs have only slightly better than a coin-flip chance of matching derm or neurosurg. Match rates for osteopathic is slightly lower. For foreign old pupils it is exponentially tougher to match, due to a combination of questionable international curriculum standardization, language barriers, decrease training reimbursement by Medicare for foreign grads, and good old fashioned prejudice.
Related Questions: